Close reading: Using metaphors in data analysis

The workshop was organised by Realities – part of the ESRC National Centre for Research Methods

Why analyse metaphor?
Metaphor is recognised as an important way of thinking – constructing analogies and making connections between ideas – and an important way of using language – to explain abstract ideas or to find indirect but powerful ways of conveying feelings. By investigating people’s use of metaphors, we suggest that we can better understand their emotions, attitudes and conceptualisations, as individuals and as participants in social life (excerpt taken from the OU Metaphor analysis project website).

What are metaphors?
The metaphor expert on the day was Professor Lynne Cameron from the Open University and she introduced the basic definition of metaphors, which was very useful:
“the phenomenon whereby we talk and potentially think about something in terms of something else” (Semino, E. 2008 Metaphor and Discourse. Cambridge. CUP).

It was also very interesting that Lynne explained further that metaphors could be grouped/connected by shared topics and in this way you could identify big patterns (she referred to this as systematic metaphors). For example, talking about life as a journey is a very common pattern. Another one is talking about time as money; i.e spending time, value the time, counting hours etc.

Then we all had a go at identifying metaphors in a data extract and the extent to which language is littered with metaphors soon became apparent. My use of “littered” in the previous sentence is an excellent example of a metaphor.

Why use metaphor analysis?
I found the practical exercises really useful and reading my data/text very closely meant paying attention to the ways people are using language/metaphors. I see it as a practice that can underpin (yet another metaphor!) the thematic analysis I already undertake on qualitative data. There was also a feeling that themes already identified in a data set could be explored in more detail by then looking in more detail at the metaphors and any big patterns to emerge from the data.

It was also suggested that metaphors could be useful in guiding how data was written up, as they can be great tools for communicating abstract ideas, complexity and connections.

Kathrine

Useful links:

Researching and Applying Metaphor International Association

More on the metaphor workshop details

A classic text dealing with metaphors is “Metaphors we live by” by George Lakoff and Mark Johnson. Read more on conceptual metaphor.

Journals:

Metaphor and the social world

Metaphor and Symbol

 

Advertisements

About talintuoh

Supporting and connecting colleagues to develop inspiring and innovative teaching and learning
This entry was posted in Research, Training, writing. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Close reading: Using metaphors in data analysis

  1. Saundra says:

    greetings, awesome article, and a fairly good understand! one for my favorites.

  2. This is the second article, of your blog I actually checked out.
    Although I really enjoy this specific one, “Close reading: Using metaphors in data
    analysis | Teaching and Learning Institute” the most.
    Thank you ,Raleigh

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s